JUDGES SHAME ON YOU ALL

Yahoo!7

JUDGES SHAME ON YOU ALL

Create Reply

Page 3 of 3

First Page
< Previous
Next >
Last Page

Sort By:: Newest First; Oldest First

Shamaniac
19 Nov 2010
Sign in to report this post.

Posted Mon 26 Mar 2012 13:59

zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz.....

....... i'm Derryn Grinch... shame shame shame....

Shamaniac
19 Nov 2010
Sign in to report this post.

Posted Mon 26 Mar 2012 14:02

they basically got all 9's.... the two judges who had a piece of gravel.. of which one only 'thought' she might've... they dropped a point off for the oversight... get over it.. ffs

TH

Sign in to report this post.

Posted Mon 26 Mar 2012 14:03

I believe the better team won last night

TH

Sign in to report this post.

Posted Mon 26 Mar 2012 14:07

I believe the better team won last night

Shamaniac
19 Nov 2010
Sign in to report this post.

Posted Mon 26 Mar 2012 14:09

you can say that again.... oh.. you did...

Craig
1 second ago
Sign in to report this post.

Posted Mon 26 Mar 2012 14:14

To the Judges - The score I'm scoring for last night scoring challenge is a ONE. Nice to see that Thomas and Carla are not the only ones that can score strategically.....................

EB Sara 777
26 Mar 2012
Sign in to report this post.

Posted Mon 26 Mar 2012 14:28

Some users of this forum need to grow the hell up!
THIS IS A TV SHOW! It may or may NOT be rigged, but who the heck cares? Drama will be DRAMA and if you think it is rigged....#$%$ OFF!

frugal
13 Mar 2012
Sign in to report this post.

Posted Mon 26 Mar 2012 14:32

has anyone here had a thought about what M&A served up. Sure it looked nice but really think about the dishes.. pork rolls.......10 year old stuff......seafood in a hollowed out bread with a sauce.. woop de doo 14 yr olds learn this in home ec. The dessert looked ok but very plain.
I originally thought they were hard done by but on reflection not so. The girls would have got 10's for their entree and dessert and around a 6 for the main. 26 out of 30 divide by 3 an average of around 9 which they got

Janice Richards
25 Nov 2010
Sign in to report this post.

Posted Mon 26 Mar 2012 16:15

Did the judges score on an overrall basis Or did they only judge yesterday's challenge? I'm a bit confused---- I thought yesterday was the 1st semi finals? Though Jen and Leigh have cooked some great dishes over the series, yesterday's challenge was not their best. I ain't eating raw pigeon for sure/ neither am I having gravel in my food. What M & A cooked up last --- could'nt fault it, maybe that's why they looked quite shocked !!!

robert f
10 Nov 2008
Sign in to report this post.

Posted Mon 26 Mar 2012 20:28

little dee, several chefs have posted otherwise, no way i would accept a dish served in that way,blood red is undercooked not just rare & the skin wasn't crisped either.
do you honestly think any of the judges would allow that dish to go out of there kitchens, if so your deluded

Shayne and beck
18 Dec 2008
Sign in to report this post.

Posted Mon 26 Mar 2012 21:10

we agree.the hole show is a joke.we will b not watching this show again.shame on the judges.

pig baby
24 Mar 2012
Sign in to report this post.

Posted Mon 26 Mar 2012 21:16

"Pigeon must certainly be served rare, the French like to serve them almost raw but I prefer rare and certainly no more than medium rare, an overcooked pigeon is of little use for anything other than the stockpot. "

from www.gourmetfoodsource.com

Who knew?

I think It's obvious that Jen is a gifted cook. Even though I was certainly not keen on the look of that pigeon, she knows what she's doing.

Felicity
09 Oct 2008
Sign in to report this post.

Posted Mon 26 Mar 2012 21:40

Totally agree that put my husband and myself off the show.
Half heartedly watching it now but don't think we will bother next time. Just maybe Dr Evil saw something some of us didn't maybe
it wasn't all sour grapes after all.
Can't believe I said that but there you go.

Little Dee
08 Oct 2008
Sign in to report this post.

Posted Mon 26 Mar 2012 21:42

blood red is undercooked not just rare ....robert f
******

Blood red was the beetroot they served with it.

Just saying!

Gene

Sign in to report this post.

Posted Mon 26 Mar 2012 21:48

what about in one of the episodes, carly and emily left a cherry pip in the meal. I think they got a lower score for that didn't they?

Little Dee
08 Oct 2008
Sign in to report this post.

Posted Mon 26 Mar 2012 21:53

Gene they would also have got a lower score for the main meal. Remember that they are scored for all 3 meals. If both dessert and entree were a 10 (which is very likely with how well they cooked) then a score of 4 would still have them at an 8 which is what those with gravel gave them. 10+10+4=24. 24/3=8.

Ebony
1 second ago
Sign in to report this post.

Posted Mon 26 Mar 2012 21:54

Yes it's all untreated fairly Andy and Meg's best seafood cook done well they should of won they didn't have gravel in there food or baked beans that dish what the sisters did looked shocking I would not pay for my meal if that came to my table at a restraunt I would simply walk out without even paying that would turn me of gravel in food and they got 9s it's all a shame really the judges arnt judging properly there only picking the favorites they love the sisters of course

Ebony
1 second ago
Sign in to report this post.

Posted Mon 26 Mar 2012 21:58

Ebsara777 ok but would you honestly say you would sit and eat gravel in your food or would you rather the rolls simple dish I think I would rather the simple dish pork rolls then to eat gravel in my dinner that's for sure

pig baby
24 Mar 2012
Sign in to report this post.

Posted Mon 26 Mar 2012 22:01

Specks of grit. Grit happens. Deal with it.

Pat
1 second ago
Sign in to report this post.

Posted Mon 26 Mar 2012 22:08

It is very hard to argue when you are all talking sense. Last night's result was appalling.... Never eating pigeon!!!!

wahchin_b
20 Jul 2009
Sign in to report this post.

Posted Mon 26 Mar 2012 22:21

Are all the moaners Tassies?

Go SA!!!!

Inna
17 Dec 2008
Sign in to report this post.

Posted Mon 26 Mar 2012 22:28

THE 1-ST SEMI FINAL SHOULD BE RE-RUN!!!
IT WAS A SHAM!!!

richard
09 Oct 2008
Sign in to report this post.

Posted Fri 13 Apr 2012 13:23

Wife and I are from Canada and fell in love with the show while on vacation in your country, managed to download it and finish the series when we came back believing it was a better than average reality cooking show. Have gotten a few co workers into to it as well and we have all arrived at the same blood conclusion. What a load of #$%$ from the jury and their b.s. and then finally this sham. Can't add any more than what you guys all said. What a shame, I shan't bother to try and download anymore of this is the kind of fixing if they intend to keep this garbage up.
Loved my visit, beautiful country.
Cheers
Richard
Canada

Thenmoli
18 Sep 2009
Sign in to report this post.

Posted Wed 01 Aug 2012 21:17

Exactly!! I was thinking of posting the same issue here. I mean there was dirt found in the food and the pigeon was raw. And yet they won the round? Meaning it's okay to server you guest with food that was not clean properly? Megan and Andy put a lots of effort in making their dish. This was totally unfair? It seems as if things were meant to be that way just to run the show. Frankly speaking, i lost the interest in watching the show after the unfairness that happened to Megan and Andy....